On choosing to be non-binary
Published on 2026-11-16
Recently I read a manga series called Welcome Back, Alice by Shūzō Oshimi. I'd first heard of Oshimi from a YouTube video essay I suppose I would have watched around three years ago:
That video thoroughly spoiled his more famous series Inside Mari, so I added Welcome Back, Alice to my reading list. Which is where it languished for the following three years until I finally came across a translated copy last week.
The series was interesting. It deals with the obviously very familiar themes of growing up and learning to love as a non-binary person. The challenges that poses in a cisheteronormative society. How disgusting and personally abusive it is to try and love someone as a cisgender person when you know you aren't. Importantly, though, Oshimi never uses the word non-binary to describe any of his characters. He never uses the word "cisgender," either. It's lightly implied that the people in the world of Welcome Back, Alice have a concept of transgender people, but nobody's ever said to be trans.
In a 2020 article, Chris Cimi criticizes Oshimi for not committing to calling the lead, explicitly genderqueer character Kei what they are, opting instead to have them describe themself in terms like "not a boy anymore," or "neither a boy nor a girl."
Unlike Cimi in that moment, I have access to the whole story and it kind of feels like Oshimi isn't reluctant to call Kei genderqueer, but rather that he might not even know what that means.
Oshimi does this thing where he includes intensely personal reflections on his own exploration of gender identity at the end of each volume. Not unlike… your current author. In them he describes himself more or less the same way he has Kei describe themself: neither a boy nor a girl. But he never goes so far as to call himself genderqueer, or anything similar. He acknowledges that it's possible for someone to be neither male nor female, but he seems to think this is a world of pure contradiction. In the afterword to the final volume, he says he felt so isolated by it that he started researching it, hoping someone, anyone, would have the language to describe this strange and disorienting experience.
At this point, my Westerner-ass is standing up in the theatre shouting "Judith Butler! Judith Butler!" But no, instead he comes upon this much more psychosexual explanation of where these feelings come from in Japanese philosopher Masahiro Morioka's book Confessions of a Frigid Man. Ostensibly, Oshimi's own reflections on this would lead to the creation of Welcome Back, Alice, a series that seems to be about inventing non-binary people from first principles.
Obviously, power to him, you know. I get it. I'm also the kind of person to dump out all their deepest feelings for others to read. I know when you do something like that, you risk weirdos (me) coming across it, projecting their own feelings and misinterpreting everything you wrote.¹ It feels hard to believe that someone could write a series like Welcome Back, Alice in the 2020s and not make any connections to the broader culture of genderqueerness that exists in every part of the world, but I'm not him, and gender identity is everyone's journey and theirs alone. Not to mention, I don't know shit about Japan. I have no idea what it's like to grow up with those kinds of feelings in Japan.
I'm non-binary because I had ostensibly those same feelings in Canada, and someone told me that's what it means to be non-binary. For the longest time I chose not to be, because it seemed easier to do what people expected of me. To be a man. But eventually I couldn't bear it any longer. I chose… to be non-binary.
Don't get me wrong; I didn't choose to be who I am. I tried really hard not to be. But I wasn't always "non-binary," nor was I always a man before that. For the longest time, I told myself in private that I was agender. The people in my life especially didn't like that one, because they found it confusing. That kept me deep in the closet for a lot longer than I might have otherwise been. When I first came out to my friends I told them that I was genderfluid, because that's what made the most sense to me at the time. Later, again, I found it was too much work to explain, so I settled on "non-binary." Most people kind of know what it means to be non-binary, even if they don't get it. It's just a catch-all term used to describe someone who's neither a boy nor a girl. Non-binary is a thought-terminating cliché.
I have long been keen on the notion of gender performativity—the idea that you are not your gender so much as it's something that comes into existence through the way you interact with others. I think this is a flatly more useful way of understanding gender identity. Obviously non-binary "means" something to many people (myself included, for what it's worth) and what it means to each of us individually is, I suppose, the qualities of gender we create and are created for us as we exist in the social world. If it means something deeply personal to you, don't let me calling it a "thought-terminating cliché" get in the way of that. Otherwise, maybe that simple assertion that the specifics don't really matter is something you can find peace in. I suppose I probably did at some point. But I guess I do kind of want to be critical of myself for giving up on trying to understand what that really means—for allowing it to be entirely defined by others, to be the passive recipient of whatever the most normal people on Earth think "being non-binary" really is.
The biogeochemical girl exists in a context. She is co-created, by herself and those she willingly allows to help shape her. Honestly I don't have a new fun environmental science name for what I'm describing here but it's the same idea. I guess it just took reading the tortured account of someone else trying to invent non-binaryness from first principles to realize I never really figured it out myself, and that maybe I should get back to it.
Footnotes
Respond to this article
If you have thoughts you'd like to share, send me an email!